Skip to content

Concrete vs Plastic Water Tanks: We Compare

Concrete vs Plastic Water Tanks Green Tank

A water tank is almost a must-have in rural New Zealand for both saving water and money. So then, what type of water tank is right for you? When comparing concrete vs plastic water tanks, factors like durability, cost, and material should all be considered; however, researching which of the two options is the right choice can be a lengthy task. With that in mind, we thought we’d do the hard work for you and compare them below to help you make a more informed choice.

Plastic Water Tanks

Recently plastic water tanks have been the industry's preferred option over concrete. This is because of their leak-proof, lightweight, economical, rust-proof, durable, easy to transport, and very low maintenance design. Not only that, but you can get plastic tanks in various shapes and sizes, including slimline versions, making them a versatile choice.

Advantages

  • Leak-proof — Robust and durable construction means you won't have to worry about costly leaks.
  • Lightweight — compared to a concrete tank, plastic tanks are far lighter, making them more portable and more versatile with the ability to switch locations if needed.
  • Corrosion and rust-proof,
  • More budget-friendly

Advantages

  • If for some reason, the plastic coating on the tank is damaged, the water tank can become brittle from UV exposure.
  • Water in plastic water tanks will be warmer during the summer months than water held in a concrete tank.

Concrete Water Tanks

So, how do concrete water tanks hold up when comparing concrete vs plastic Water Tanks? Concrete water tanks are the older option on the market. You can get them in a range of shapes, from round to rectangular, and they're very durable and sturdy. However, there are benefits and drawbacks to consider with concrete, just as there is with plastic.

Advantages

  • Relatively easy to clean
  • Longer life compared to plastic water tanks (up to 50 years)
  • Keeps water much cooler during the hot summer months


Disadvantages

  • Being the heavy material that concrete is, it is very difficult, if not impossible, to move once you get it in place. This is even before you add water to it.
  • Concrete tanks are costly. Putting aside the tank's initial cost, transport and excavation are also, on average, more expensive than plastic, meaning overall project costs add up very quickly.
  • With multiple joins in each structure, cracking in a concrete water tank is more likely. Without regular maintenance, you increase the chances of cracks forming even further.

Also, even though concrete won't rust, it is prone to corrosion, which can also cause eventual leaks if you don't catch it right away.

Concrete vs Plastic Water Tanks — Comparison Table

Plastic Water Tanks

Concrete Water Tanks

Colour Resistance (UV Rays)

Low resistance to UV light

High resistance to UV light

Construction

Easy installation process

Requires skilled contractors

to make it waterproof

Cost

More budget-friendly

Expensive, especially installation

Flexibility 

Connection point is flexible

Connection point is rigid

Leakage

Not prone to leaking

Prone to leaking without routine maintenance

Maintenance

Lower cost — virtually maintenance-free

Higher maintenance costs

and needs

Material

Lightweight but durable polyethylene

Heavily reinforced concrete

Shape

Cubical or cylindrical

Virtually any shape or size, 

depending on your needs

Size

1,000L to over 30,000L

Built to any size capacity

Strength

Lower breaking point

Very high breaking point

Temperature

Water may be warmer during summer

Water stays cool all year round

Transportation

Very portable and easy to move

Very difficult or immovable

Warranty

Usually comes with a pro-rata warranty

Typically not covered by a pro-rata warranty

 

Contact Rural Water NZ for High-Quality Plastic Water Tanks

When it comes to Concrete vs Plastic Water Tanks it’s important to weigh up the pro’s and cons for your particular situation. At a glance, plastic tanks offer far more benefits than concrete ones, especially if you want something durable that won't break your budget, At Rural Water NZ, we have a host of quality plastic water tanks to suit your needs. We invite you to browse our stock and make your selection. If you're unsure, reach out to our professional and friendly staff for a free water tank quote today.

Previous article 9 Reasons Why Rural Water is NZ’s Preferred Place To Buy a Water Tank.
Next article 5 Simple Ways to Save Water at Home
Pay by LayBuy